Tap to unmute

Mixing Every Oreo Flavor Together

Teilen
Einbetten
  • Am 28 Sep 2022 veröffentlicht
  • HELLO FRIENDS!! Today we’re gonna be combining every flavor of oreo that we could find into a franken-oreo, but we’re going to be turning it into a little friendly competition that we’re calling “The Frank-Off”. Tyler has one method of making this monstrosity and Safiya has another. Let’s see which one will win out!
    You can check out our merch here!! fiendishbehavior.com
    Produced & Edited by
    Carly Dawson
    Nez Covington
    Tyler Williams
    Safiya Nygaard
    GFX by
    Dayana Espinoza
    MUSIC
    Via Audio Network

KOMMENTARE • 3 546

  • Tyler Williams
    Tyler Williams  Vor Monat +3098

    Hello and welcome to this video! Who do you think won the frank-off and made the best ~franken-oreo~? My cookies ‘n’ cream approach or Saf's single soggy cookie? Let us know in the comments below!

    • Charmayne
      Charmayne Vor 28 Tage

      Saft cookie!

    • Aumna Iqbal
      Aumna Iqbal Vor 28 Tage

      single cookie is the true franken

    • loladoeswcue
      loladoeswcue Vor Monat

      saf

    • icedmatcha
      icedmatcha Vor Monat

      I loved this experiment, everything is edible!! 🍪🥛🍪🥛🍪🥛

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Hello and welcome to this video / Who do you think won the frank - off and made the best - franken - oreo - / My cookies / n / cream approach or Saf / s single soggy cookie / Let us know in the comments below /

  • {dillion}
    {dillion} Vor Monat +1501

    oreo should make a “sampler pack” with a bunch of different flavors so i personally can determine my favorite flavor without buying every kind

    • Dee Normus
      Dee Normus Vor 3 Tage

      I’ve been asking for this for at least 15 years. Why do they not hear us?! Come on, Oreo! Sample. Pack. Sample. Pack. Sample! Pack!

    • Alyssa Glass
      Alyssa Glass Vor 9 Tage

      They seriously need to do this. I love trying the new area flavors but never get through even half the pack before I'm over it lol.

    • AirJayden2324
      AirJayden2324 Vor Monat +2

      This person is big brain

    • IchhabeKeineAhnung 2
      IchhabeKeineAhnung 2 Vor Monat +4

      i wonder if an oreo Christmas calendar exists. would be a nice and expensive way to eat the variety of flavours

    • JK
      JK Vor Monat +1

      Honestly every brand that has several different flavours of the same thing should do this, it's so annoying.

  • Alana Dyer
    Alana Dyer Vor Monat +1458

    Saf is getting my vote because she took the literal definition of the Franken-series. Mixing it all together into 1 product 🤣

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat +1

      Saf is getting my vote because she took the literal definition of the Franken - series . Mixing it all together into 1 product

    • Ryn Lane
      Ryn Lane Vor Monat +3

      I agree

  • Super Nintendo Chalmers
    Super Nintendo Chalmers Vor Monat +2487

    Saf's face when she realized she coulda made one giant Oreo 😭🤣

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Saf / s face when she realized she coulda made one giant Oreo

    • Anja R
      Anja R Vor Monat

      @Cupcake_ if you liked it then I would be 500 like but now I'm 499😤

    • LG Hakubi
      LG Hakubi Vor Monat +14

      Yeah I thought they were going giant Oreo too, or at least more than one. But they do have another 18 flavors of cookies leftover to consider so having a batch of mixed mushy probably isn't ideal 😅

    • Metzli
      Metzli Vor Monat +8

      That's where I thought she was headed xD

    • saris_21
      saris_21 Vor Monat +6

      I thought of it 😭

  • Eileen Conway
    Eileen Conway Vor Monat +1298

    People say that love is dead, but we still have Tyler and Saf.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      People say that love is dead , but we still have Tyler and Saf .

    • JELLYcat
      JELLYcat Vor Monat +2

      just solid facts😌

    • itzmeee
      itzmeee Vor Monat +3

      When was it ever dead? There are so many couples in this world right now

    • Christine
      Christine Vor Monat +13

      ShhHhhhHhhh before yet another internet or traditional celebrity hears you & cheats on their partner lol

    • Dilara - Creating Love
      Dilara - Creating Love Vor Monat +3

      @-Bonny- r u-?

  • Hi High•
    Hi High• Vor Monat +450

    I love how they’re expecting us to choose the winner without us even tasting it.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I love how they're expecting us to choose the winner without us even tasting it .

    • Moonlight
      Moonlight Vor Monat +1

      @Izzybubbles 7 I replied to the wrong comment lol

    • Izzybubbles 7
      Izzybubbles 7 Vor Monat +2

      @Moonlight why?

    • Moonlight
      Moonlight Vor Monat +3

      This comment is a prime contender for a "didn't age well" award.

    • chibyi.
      chibyi. Vor Monat +8

      aesthetics bruh

  • Callieann93
    Callieann93 Vor Monat +3223

    Safiya’s ability to describe flavors/scents is seriously unmatched.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Safiya / s ability to describe flavors / scents is seriously unmatched .

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Safiya ability to describe flavor / scents is seriously unmatched

    • Blue
      Blue Vor Monat

      @Morgan P. Probably not

    • luiza <3
      luiza <3 Vor Monat +1

      FRRRR COOKING CHANNEL COULD NEVER

    • stella monchen
      stella monchen Vor Monat +3

      I like how Safiya can describe and compare the flavors, but sometimes the comparisons just go completely over my head, considering I'm not American ^^'

  • CurveTheRain
    CurveTheRain Vor Monat +130

    Tyler and Saf: we taste each individual flavor
    Carly: hmmm I’m getting…. Oreo. 😂

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Tyler and Saf / we taste each individual flavor Carly / hmmm l / m getting ... Oreo .

  • May Tuccolo
    May Tuccolo Vor Monat +176

    Lmao I love how Saf and Tyler make it seem like they have exquisite palettes and Carly is just plain

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Lmao l love how Saf and Tyler makes it seem like they have exquisite palettes and Carly is just plain

  • Randy Romines
    Randy Romines Vor Monat +138

    Usually Tyler is back up to Safiya's lead so it was refreshing to see him come out in the forefront for a change! I had to giggle, I have the exact same knife set and plastic ware the ice cream was put in. Considering that we are not comparing 2 cookies - Saf wins the cookie category and Tyler wins the ice cream category!

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Usually Tyler is back up to Safiya / s lead it was refreshing to see him come out in the fore front for a change / l had to giggle , l have the exact same knife set and plastic ware the ice cream was put in . Considering that we are not comparing 2 cookies - Saf wins the cookie category and Tyler wins the ice cream category /

  • Laura V
    Laura V Vor Monat +86

    in Europe we have basically no special flavours but the only one we do have is the one missing from your selection which is strawberry cheesecake 😂

    • Delancey
      Delancey Vor 9 Tage

      In Europe we have basically no special flavors but the only one we do have is the one missing from your selection which is strawberry cheesecake 😂

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      in Europe we have basically no special flavours but the only one we do have is the one missing from your selection which is strawberry cheesecake

  • Kendall
    Kendall Vor Monat +11795

    Safiya mixing lipgloss: here comes trouble
    Tyler mixing Oreos: make it double

    • Life is hard
      Life is hard Vor 17 Tage

      Stuffed? Double stuffed Oreo? I get it, funny joke haha

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Safiya mixing lipgloss / here comes trouble Tyler mixing Oreos / make it double

    • jyp
      jyp Vor Monat

      To protect the world from devastation
      To unite all peoples within our nation
      To denounce the evils of truth and love
      To extend our reach to the stars above
      Jessie, James
      Team Rocket, blast off at the speed of light
      Surrender now or prepare to fight (that's right)

    • Sarah Dacey
      Sarah Dacey Vor Monat +1

      Wait can we have a video making these costumes?

    • Heidi Samuels
      Heidi Samuels Vor Monat

      @GoAway LeaveMeAlone No, we all knew it from the start!

  • Darin Glavan
    Darin Glavan Vor Monat +73

    One thing we’ve learned from this video is that Carly is NOT a super taster, but we love her all the same haha

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      One things we / ve learned from this is that Carly is NOT a super taster , but we love her all the same haha

  • Karen Kwan
    Karen Kwan Vor Monat +80

    Ty: I think another way to incorporate more of the "flavor" into the ice cream would be to melt the cream into the ice cream base
    Saf: Maybe baking the cookie and using less butter would've helped with structure, a bit like a cheesecake crust

  • Lilo
    Lilo Vor Monat +24

    Oreo DID have a soft cookie, and it was AMAZING. The Oreo Cakesters. I need them to be brought back!!

    • Mal Mao
      Mal Mao Vor 11 Tage +1

      Oh they back! Bought a pack two weeks ago and they are delicious!

    • Olga Hdz
      Olga Hdz Vor 13 Tage +1

      I saw them at the store recently ! I think they’re back!

    • Jordan C
      Jordan C Vor 22 Tage +2

      @Jesse Herrera I could've sworn I recently saw an ad for them. But maybe I'm crazy

  • Milo McMahon
    Milo McMahon Vor Monat +13

    I think the ice cream was a really lovely idea, but the cookie is a clear winner - the Franken-concept was executed perfectly, and it tasted good :) Unless it had tasted awful, I still think Saf would have been the winner

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I think the ice cream was a really lovely idea , but the cookie is a clear winner - the Franken - concept was executed perfectly and it tasted good / / Unless it had tasted awful , l still think Saf would have been the winner

  • LazyNoodle
    LazyNoodle Vor Monat +4370

    I love how Carly is just destroying both of their souls by being like "tastes like regular cookies and cream" and "tastes like oreo to me" 😂 truly an icon from behind the camera

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat +1

      I love how Carly is just destroying both of their souls by being like * tastes like regular cookies and cream * and * tastes like oreo to me * truly an icon from behind the camera

    • Seannanana
      Seannanana Vor Monat +4

      I was laughing so hard at the "ooh" reaction behind the camera hahaha

    • Iam Reborn👀
      Iam Reborn👀 Vor Monat

      @iiNDiie1 awe I'm glad you think so sweetie and also it's so cute how you like your own comments. Have a nice life and good riddance

    • iiNDiie1
      iiNDiie1 Vor Monat +8

      @Iam Reborn👀 because you seem so fun at parties 🙄

    • art-and-a-half
      art-and-a-half Vor Monat +2

      Probably how I'd react lmao

  • Sarah Weaver
    Sarah Weaver Vor Monat +8

    although the cookies and cream looks delicious, I've gotta vote for safs as the true Franken Oreo. it sticks with the similar method of Franken that we have come to expect.
    Tyler gets points tho for creating something new and fun!

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      although the cookies and cream looks delicious , l / ve gotta vote for safs as the true Franken Oreo . it sticks with the similar method of Franken that we have come to expect . Tyler gets points tho for creating something new and fun /

  • Ellie Ryczek
    Ellie Ryczek Vor Monat +8

    I love Safiya's approach to this, but I was waiting for her to make more cookies and bake them to get that nice crunch with a buttery boost 👌🏻

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat +1

      I love Safiya / s approach to this , but l was waiting for her to make more cookies and bake them to get that nice crunch with a buttery boost

  • shambles.
    shambles. Vor Monat +7

    If I had a nickel for every time I’ve heard Tyler do a Goldmember impression, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      If l had a nickel for every time l / ve heard Tyler do a Goldmember impression , l / d two nickels . Which isn / t lot , but weird that it happened twice .

  • Angelic Asysnila
    Angelic Asysnila Vor Monat +18

    Safia's friend : i have leftovers of like 10 dishes from today's party, what do I do
    Safia : lemme think of a name first, franken-

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Safia / s friend / i have leftovers of like 10 dishes from today / s party , what do l do Safia / lemme think of a name first , franken -

  • Marissa Stewart
    Marissa Stewart Vor Monat +2056

    The ultimate franken-oreo snack would be mini ice cream sandwiches with Saf's cookies and Tyler's ice cream!

  • Angelic Asysnila
    Angelic Asysnila Vor Monat +14

    I wish all those variants were available in my country. Like cheesecake flavoured Oreo ??? I would be in oreo heaven 🤤

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I wish all those variants were available in my country . Like cheese cake flavoured Oreo /// l would be in oreo heaven

  • Stephanie Wayman
    Stephanie Wayman Vor Monat +11

    I am loving the influx of Tyler content! The food angle is great!

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I am lovkng the influx of Tyler content / The food angle is great /

  • JK
    JK Vor Monat +4

    I'm soooooooooooo happy you guys are posting more videos that are under the 30 minute mark. They're so wonderful for relaxing at lunch time when you're working or just having a wee break after work before you start running around at home, and I love seeing you guys interact with one another but also still showcase all of Saf's beautiful talents, while getting to enjoy Ty both behind and in front of the camera as well. I still like the videos where Saf is in front of the camera and Ty is behind the camera VERY much, no shade! I just also think it's nice to sometimes see Ty and Saf with their sweet banter and strangely supportive relationship. It might even help normalise supportive relationships! 😂😂

  • Sister. M. Joan Henderson

    Now I think Nabisco should make the Frankencookie official and do it non-soggy, that would be awesome!

  • PS1 Hagrid ouf of character

    Safiya's method was more true to the franken-spirit, but honestly i think having a whole batch of delicious ice cream is much more rewarding than a single delicious cookie 😂😂

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Safiya / s method was more true to the franken - spirit , but honestly i think having a whole batch of delicious ice cream is much more rewarding than a single delicious cookie

    • TheEliseRodgers
      TheEliseRodgers Vor Monat +8

      Yeah.
      It looked like they had plenty of “dust” in the blender for more cookies so kind of a wasted opportunity of “FrankenMaterial” (because she also cut at least 4 “Franken-creams”, and it looked like more could have been cut from that too)

    • Jessica Lo
      Jessica Lo Vor Monat +9

      I totally agree. With the ice cream, you have more of a reward at the end as you have more product to eat and savor

    • thundercaya
      thundercaya Vor Monat +33

      They had enough Franken cream and Franken crumbs to make more cookies but I guess they only had one mold?

  • Álex Souto
    Álex Souto Vor Monat

    Carly is my spirit animal
    "I taste cookies and cream"
    "It taste like Oreo 🤷"

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Carly is my spirit animal * l taste cookies and cream * * lt taste like Oreo

  • Cloud ☁️
    Cloud ☁️ Vor Monat +1

    My favorite flavor of Oreo will always be red velvet, it is so good!! 😂

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      My favorite flavor of Oreo will always be red velvet , it is so good //

  • zeskiyo
    zeskiyo Vor Monat

    I really thought she was going for a giant oreo when she first poured it. Then she spread it and I was like "or maybe not." Her face when she realises she missed an opportunity is so precious! 😂 Tyler's looked (and probably tasted) better, but both did great!

  • Lisa Stenzel
    Lisa Stenzel Vor Monat

    I love you guys so much! You make me laugh so hard!! You two never let go of each other. You are awesome together... unseperable, unlike oreos 😅😂

    • DEEMAN TV
      DEEMAN TV Vor Monat

      This comment mean so much to me , you're selected as one of the winners on my weekly G.I.V.EAWAY . Message the above highlighted ( name ) don't hesitations!

  • V, stop bias wrecking me
    V, stop bias wrecking me Vor Monat +10168

    honestly Tyler's a franken cookies and cream, whereas Safiya's an actual franken oreo

  • Tabitha Clark
    Tabitha Clark Vor 26 Tage

    Saf has my vote! The Oreo she made was the definition of a mash up of all the Oreos

  • Anna Maria
    Anna Maria Vor 9 Tage

    Personally I feel that the ice cream was probably the superior product, but there was too much additional flavour for it to really be judged as a Franken Oreo, because most things taste nice if you put them into decent home made ice cream 🤷🏻‍♀️

  • Whinnie_Girl
    Whinnie_Girl Vor Monat +13

    I like how the holiday oreos were strawberry, lemon and carrot cake, when there are literally halloween, christmas and spring oreos

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I like how the holiday oreos were strawberry , lemon and carrot cake , when there are literally halloween , christmas and spring oreos

    • TiBun
      TiBun Vor Monat +1

      Those holiday oreos are the basic oreos with food coloring in the frosting and a holiday mold on the cookie rather than the basic oreo pattern and logo, so it wouldn't have lended much to the flavor like the seasonal flavors they did use and mistakenly called holiday. That said, they did miss other seasonal flavors like the pumpkin spice oreos that are now on shelves.

  • Beth SL
    Beth SL Vor 20 Tage

    Franken -off needs to be a series of this chanel! Love this.

  • tangerine
    tangerine Vor Monat +1

    I would prefer to eat Tyler's ice cream, but Safiya's cookie(s) stay true to the spirit, so my vote goes to the soggy single cookie. My bet is that Tyler's homemade ice cream isn't better than my sister's, hehe.

  • Candice Parkin
    Candice Parkin Vor Monat

    New favorite channel! You guys are an hilarious team! 😍🙌🏼

    • DEEMAN TV
      DEEMAN TV Vor Monat

      This comment mean so much to me , you're selected as one of the winners on my weekly G.I.V.EAWAY . Message the above highlighted ( name ) don't hesitations!

  • nluther22
    nluther22 Vor Monat +5

    Carly’s “ohs” are hysterical 😂

  • snurfbee58
    snurfbee58 Vor 15 Tage

    From your reactions they both seem amazing. But, I'm an ice cream girl for sure so I would go for the ice cream.

  • Jen Pink
    Jen Pink Vor Monat

    They both look so delicious 😋 but Ik I would like Tyler’s ice cream 🍨

  • Aly De La Cruz
    Aly De La Cruz Vor Monat +1

    Loved seeing that chicken jello mold in the fridge 😂

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Loved seeing that chicken jello mold in the frdge

  • superboobs890
    superboobs890 Vor Monat +5

    I love that the lipgloss scrapers are being put to good use 😆

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I love that the li pg loss scarapers are being put to good use

  • Alssadarya M
    Alssadarya M Vor Monat

    For practicality and end product, Tyler's icecream would win for me. You get more servings out of it but the taste seems more prominent with Saf's cookie. Tough one!

  • RandiPoitras
    RandiPoitras Vor Monat +1864

    Semantically, Saf’s Oreo is THE franken Oreo

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Semantically , Saf / s Oreo is THE franken Oreo

    • NeRethil Wolfsson
      NeRethil Wolfsson Vor Monat +65

      Saf made Franken-Oreo.
      Tyler made Franken-Oreo-topped McFlurry.
      And that is beautiful.

  • CC
    CC Vor Monat

    6:19 Saf, you’re about an hour of good practice away from doing a spot on Dame Maggie Smith impression (professor mcgonagall from Harry Potter) Lolol
    Also, as someone who likes Oreos dipped in milk, a gooey Oreo sounds like heaven.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      6 / 19 Saf , you / re about an hour of good practice away from doing a spot on Dame Maggie Smith impression / professor mcgonagall from Harry Potter / Lolol Also , as someone who likes Oreos dipped in milk , a gooey Oreo sound like heaven .

  • Fancy Chancey
    Fancy Chancey Vor Monat +1

    Please make a giant franken cookie cake!! That would be so awesome!

  • Codi Marie
    Codi Marie Vor Monat +1

    Idk if I can trust Tyler’s taste buds anymore after he said the birthday cake ones are disgusting!!
    Also who eats 5-6 Oreos chocolate peanut butter pie and somehow say you didn’t like them...

  • Elin
    Elin Vor Monat

    Because I always choose cookies over ice cream, I have to say the Franken-cookie wins. 🥰

  • Angélique Stevens
    Angélique Stevens Vor Monat +1793

    I am partial to Saf’s scientific approach in getting everything separated and then putting it back together 😊

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I am partial to Saf / s scientific approach in getting everything separated and then putting it back together

    • if sha
      if sha Vor Monat +4

      Yeah the other one gave me a lil headache . LoL

    • Caitlyn Shannon
      Caitlyn Shannon Vor Monat +31

      Ditto that! It really appeals to the ADHD part of my brain that insists on separating and organizing everything.

  • JK
    JK Vor Monat +1

    So mostly I don't understand what Saf is comparing flavours to because it's usually something American, but I will say the specificity of the descriptions combined with the ones I do know really makes me feel like this is the only channel I can watch and feel like I know what something tastes, smells or feels like. It's so rare! Even on cooking shows!

  • A Biggs
    A Biggs Vor Monat

    Damn now I want to do this!!! What y'all could have done for the ice cream, is soak all the cookie flavors in your ice cream base, strain and then churn. That probably would have been even more franken-y. Next up KitKat?

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Damn now l want to do this /// What y / all could have done for the ice cream , is soak all the cookie flavors in your ice cream base , strain and then churn . That probably would have been even more franken - y . Next up Kit Kat /

  • Nedread
    Nedread Vor Monat +6

    Being in Australia, it's wild to see how much variety in flavours (though most of them are likely special or limited editions) you have. The bog standard amounts that we have in my local supermarkets are original, chocolate, red velvet, and a golden one which I'm not sure what it is. Might be more, but it definitely isn't as much shown in the video xD

    • Nedread
      Nedread Vor Monat

      @concretedaisies Yep, looking at my local Coles (put post code into online shopping), we have: Original, Chocolate Creme, Strawberry Creme, Choc Split (half original creme, half chocolate), Red Velvet, Golden Creme, Double Stuff, Choc Hazelnut, and Cinnamon Bun. Those last 2 I didn't realize were a thing and tbh I'm kinda interested in the Cinnamon Bun.
      So probably 2 more than I thought we had.

    • concretedaisies
      concretedaisies Vor Monat +1

      You have golden and red velvet?! That's two more than us in NZ 🥲 although I do think I saw a strawberry one once, maybe I hallucinated that

  • Just_an_Observer
    Just_an_Observer Vor Monat +6

    They both appeal to me honestly, but I think I was drawn more to Saf's cookie than Tyler's ice cream because it felt and looked more like a franken cookie. And also just based on their reactions alone. Tyler's was really just ice cream with a bunch of Oreo toppings, but I'm sure I would find it very tasty, it'd been fun too, not knowing what flavor you were gonna get in the bite of ice cream till you took said bite

  • Erika
    Erika Vor Monat +2690

    Saf AND Tyler videos at once??? What a day!

  • Polly Pocket
    Polly Pocket Vor Monat

    Damn, I want Oreos now… Mint, Golden and OG… I guess I need to go to the store, thanks guys.

  • Erin Celine
    Erin Celine Vor 13 Tage

    I was so looking forward to seeing your reactions to Swedish Fish Oreos

  • lalapink
    lalapink Vor Monat +5

    Saf is so good at describing things! i love it!

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Saf is so good at describing things / i love it /

  • Rachel Williams
    Rachel Williams Vor Monat

    Cookie- 8.5/10 for sticking to the assignment and doing it well.
    Ice cream- 9/10 because it seemed to have a slightly better reaction and it looked more delicious.

  • Safiya Nygaard
    Safiya Nygaard Vor Monat +8581

    SINGLE SOGGY COOKIE! SINGLE SOGGY COOKIE!

  • Chivati-💖 𝐹**СК МЕ - СНЕ𝒞𝒦 𝑀𝒴 Р𝑅𝟢𝐹𝐼𝐿Е🔞

    Safiya's method was more true to the franken-spirit, but honestly i think having a whole batch of delicious ice cream is much more rewarding than a single delicious cookie

  • Catarina Baptista
    Catarina Baptista Vor Monat

    voting on the cookie, that cream looked amazing. you made me want to try all of the flavours now, thank you

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      voting on the cookie , that cream looked amazing . you made me want to try all of the flavours now , thank you

  • Kristen Rowen-Pliske

    Then chocolate cream & the lemon Oreos are my favorites. However, when they first debuted the golden Oreos, they called them Uh-Ohs. They were vanilla cookies with chocolate cream and they were the best things. They were renamed golden Oreos but sadly the chocolate cream ones didn’t last much longer. I still mourn their loss, even as I enjoy the lemon & the chocolate Oreos.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Then chocolate cream / the lemon Oreos are my favorites . How ever , when they first debuted the golden Oreos , they called them Uh - Ohs . They were vanilla cookies with chocolate cream and they were the best things . They were renamed golden Oreos but sadly things . They were renamed golden Oreos but sadly the chocolate cream ones didn't last much longer . I still mourn their loss , even as l enjoy the lemon / the chocolate Oreos .

  • ispeakfangirl
    ispeakfangirl Vor Monat

    I love how they go about their "experiment" in the most scientific way ever complete with hypothesis, methodology, even a control setup aand then cap it off with a well spoken conclusion.😅

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I love how they go about their * experiment * in the most scientific way ever complete with hyporhesis , methodolohy , even a control serup a and then cap it off with a well spoken conclusion .

  • JuliaGoolia8944
    JuliaGoolia8944 Vor Monat +580

    Is this the first franken that didn't default to a mauvy purple?? Historic!

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Is this the first franken that didn't default to a mauvy purple // Historic /

    • Sora Shirogane
      Sora Shirogane Vor Monat +1

      The franken-lushes(Bathbomb and soaps) didn't, and neither did the franken-wedding cupcake

    • Saily Kawathekar
      Saily Kawathekar Vor Monat

      Hahahaha

    • Dude
      Dude Vor Monat +1

      It's missing the raspberry ones

    • JuliaGoolia8944
      JuliaGoolia8944 Vor Monat

      @T Kay right??

  • Sandra Bollermann
    Sandra Bollermann Vor Monat +1

    Just wanted to say I love you guys. Great video ideas and good content. Thanks for creating for us!

  • Linda Wade
    Linda Wade Vor Monat +1

    I thought saf was going to make a giant Oreo until I saw how little the cream was spread

  • Yashswini 291
    Yashswini 291 Vor 29 Tage

    Finally Safiya is back!!❤

  • SunStone_XD
    SunStone_XD Vor Monat

    Awesome video! I came from Safiya's channel and you were always sort of a cool sidekick to me so it's nice to see you as the main guy

  • Hridi
    Hridi Vor Monat +2103

    For Tyler's, he could've separated the cream from the cookie and incorporate it into the vanilla icecream.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      For Tyler / s , he could / ve separated the cream from the cookie and incorporate it into the vanilla ice cream .

    • Brandie Davis
      Brandie Davis Vor Monat

      @Kaylee LaBeouf the best cookies and cream ice cream has cream flavored ice cream, though. I've had one that used plain vanilla for the base ice cream and it was meh.

    • Ivar Bjørnsen
      Ivar Bjørnsen Vor Monat

      @Shaphina There is definitely cream with the cookie biscuit, in the ice cream. Just smashed up cookie bits all up in the ice cream :) It's my favourite flavour!

    • Jroo31
      Jroo31 Vor Monat

      I thought tyler was going to do that but I saw he didnt separate them. Maybe next round when she makes a huge cookie.

    • Shaphina
      Shaphina Vor Monat +1

      @Kaylee LaBeouf I love cookies and cream ice cream but I can't say i ever remember there being the cookie cream with the cookies. Might just be the brands I've had or location. Or maybe just with the actual Oreo Branded cookies and cream ice cream?

  • Dez Mess
    Dez Mess Vor Monat

    My fave Oreo is the Fireworks one! Makes my mouth feel like a party. It’s fun lol 🥳

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      My fave Oreo is the Fireworks one / Makes my mouth feel like a party . It's fun lol

  • Cinnamon P.
    Cinnamon P. Vor Monat

    I was so sad y’all didn’t have the gingerbread Oreos in it! I love those

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I was so sad y / all didn't have the ginger bread Oreos in it / l love those

  • Sky 🌌
    Sky 🌌 Vor Monat +1

    Was anyone else really disappointed that they didn’t include pumpkin spice Oreos?
    Also if we have to pick a winner, I’d have to say Saf won just because it’s much more of a franken-cookie, while Tyler’s is an everything cookies and cream ice cream type deal.

  • Kailey Mo Becker
    Kailey Mo Becker Vor Monat

    My favorite Oreos that I’ve tried are double stuff, pistachio, and lemon.

  • Erin M
    Erin M Vor Monat +738

    lol I'm convinced Tyler just really wanted ice cream. 😂
    Safiya's frank is what I would assume the Oreo frank would be but Tyler's sounds like the better snack. 😂

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      lol l / m convinced Tyler just really wanted ice cream . Safiya / s is what l would assume the Oreo frank would be but Tyler / s sounds like the better snack .

    • TheSongwritingCat
      TheSongwritingCat Vor Monat +13

      Saf made a franken Oreo. Tyler made something I'd actually want to eat 😂

    • Pierced Siren
      Pierced Siren Vor Monat

      Exactly.

  • Erin Carter
    Erin Carter Vor Monat

    Shopping Update: Since this video came out the stores that I have gone to, on multiple occasions, have been very low stocked on Oreo Cookies. All but the original, a few mints and peanut butter varieties have been cleared out. Is it because of Halloween or is it because everyone is making franken-oreos? This is in North Carolina. Is it like this in other parts of the country?

  • Tori Cook
    Tori Cook Vor Monat +2

    Saf's franken oreo is more in line with the methodology and experience we have come to expect from the franken series! the addition of ice cream to Tyler's gives it a bit of an unfair advantage by adding in the ice cream. I mean, we all know that ice cream makes everything better. Saf wins for staying true to form!

    • Tori Cook
      Tori Cook Vor Monat

      @Jesse Herrera thanks for copy and pasting my comment back to me lol. Reported spam

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Saf / s franken oreo is more in line with the methodolohy and experience we have come to expect from the franken series / the addition of ice cream to Tyler / s gives it a bit of an unfair advantage by adding in the ice cream . mean , we all know that ice cream makes everything better . Saf wins for staying true to form /

  • Rhystlynne Cyllinz
    Rhystlynne Cyllinz Vor Monat +1

    They both look like they taste so good
    Makes me want snacks

  • Daniel Pedigo
    Daniel Pedigo Vor Monat

    Lemon Oreos are my favorite. I wish they had more fruit flavors.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Lemon Oreos are my favorite . I wish they had more fruit flavors .

  • Phoenix Owl
    Phoenix Owl Vor Monat +1246

    I vote Single Soggy Cookie because it keeps to the established formulas of the franken-series.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I vote Single Soggy Cookie because it keeps to the established formulas of franken - series .

    • Ask to seduce Miss
      Ask to seduce Miss Vor Monat +4

      a car air freshener.

  • IMBwildrd
    IMBwildrd Vor Monat

    Since Safiya's actually looked like an Oreo, I'm voting for Safiya. A franken-Oreo really should be a cookie. Plus Safiya changed the flavor by mixing it prior to entering your mouth. Tyler just cut up existing Oreo's and mixed them into homemade ice cream. He didn't really affect the flavor. The mixing happened after it was eaten. Of course, that's if you want to get technical about it. Maybe there should have been narrower rules, you needed to define what an "Oreo" is with respect to your challenge. But yeah, Safiya has my vote. Nice job! You should ask Nabisco for some royalties after they come out with something like your franken-Oreo, :)

  • puff222001
    puff222001 Vor Monat

    I think that Safiya wins by virtue of recreating the cookie itself. It's like on Buzzfeed's Worth It: if the competition is "burgers" or whatever, a restaurant shouldn't win if their burger is just OK but their fries are amazing. It's a BURGER competition. Therefore, while I admire Tyler's ingenuity, I think that Safiya wins in the spirit of the actual competition.

  • Amy Angerer
    Amy Angerer Vor Monat

    C’mon! Franken is a product all blended into one of the SAME product!!! Which tastes better is irrelevant! Saf wins HANDS DOWN! It’s just bonus that it DID taste good!!

  • madelyn
    madelyn Vor Monat +1

    You should make a franken ice cream with franken Oreos to make an ultimate franken cookies and cream 🤩

  • Celtic pack
    Celtic pack Vor Monat +866

    i love how they try to create to different versions and put all these flavors together, and carly is just like “it taste like cookies and cream.” “it taste like an oreo”

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      i love how they try to create to different version and put all these flavors together , and carly is just like * like * it taste like cookies and cream . * * it taste like an oreo *

  • OxfordPictionary
    OxfordPictionary Vor Monat +6

    I think I'd have baked Saf's cookie shells in the oven to dry them out a bit after recombining them, sort of like a cheese cake base

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I think l / d have basked Saf / s cookie shells in the oven to dry them out a bit recombining them , sort of like a cheese cake base

    • OxfordPictionary
      OxfordPictionary Vor Monat

      @Jesse Herrera There's no 's' in baked

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I think l / d have basked Saf / s cookie shells in the oven to dry them out a bit after recombining them , sort of like a cheese cake base

    • OxfordPictionary
      OxfordPictionary Vor Monat

      @Jesse Herrera bro what

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I think l / d have basked Saf / s cookie shells in the oven to dry them out a bit recombining them , sort of like a cheese cake base

  • Phoenix
    Phoenix Vor Monat +3

    I adore how efficient this is edited if that makes sense

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      I adore how efficient this is edited if that makes sense

  • Barbara
    Barbara Vor Monat

    i feel like (without tasting it of course) that the ice cream would win in taste but saf's oreo just feels more like a franken oreo.

  • Cradio
    Cradio Vor Monat

    I need to know what I’ve cream maker that is! I’ve NEVER had success with homemade ice cream because I’ve always used those old-fashioned hand crank ones, and the ice cream always comes out… icey rather than smooth and creamy. But the texture of the ice cream that came out of your machine looked perfect!

  • Kedo
    Kedo Vor Monat +345

    I love how Carly is just destroying both of their souls by being like "tastes like regular cookies and cream" and "tastes like oreo to me" 😂 truly an icon from behind the camera

  • Jakoby
    Jakoby Vor Monat

    I wish I was there so I can try it with them

  • TheStarryArcher1213

    This was fun to watch! And those mixed desserts looked yummy. Thanks for sharing this with us! ^_^
    I'm surprised that there are that many Oreo flavors. I wasn't expecting the carrot cake Oreos.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      This was fun to watch / And those mixed desserts looked yummy . Thanks for sharing this with us / + - + l / m surprised that there are that many Oreo flavors . I wasn / t expecting the carrot cake Oreos .

  • Danielle Lyon
    Danielle Lyon Vor Monat

    Although I love Safiya I have to say I think Tyler won. Now if you’d made a cheesecake with Oreo biscuit base and the creams in the centre that would have won it for me xx

  • Eileen das Neves
    Eileen das Neves Vor Monat

    You guys can put them together and you guys both win LOL! Great job you guys, great video thank you for sharing ❤️❤️💯❤️❤️

  • Paige Popovec
    Paige Popovec Vor Monat

    Carly is just the third main character on this channel and I'm loving it.

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Carly is just the third main character on this channel and l / m loving it .

  • MrsArielMoore
    MrsArielMoore Vor Monat

    I’d give it you Tyler just because there’s more to enjoy overall. But the SpongeBob burger off episode taught me that quantity isn’t as important, sooo I think Safiya wins for overall franken spirit.
    I want to do this now though!

  • xXPersondrawsXx !
    xXPersondrawsXx ! Vor 26 Tage

    I’m sad this didn’t have the cinnamon bun Oreo there so good!

  • Chi the idiot
    Chi the idiot Vor Monat

    As for actual franken-method: Saf's
    But for the one I would personally actually eat: Tyler's

  • Whimsy Cass Creations
    Whimsy Cass Creations Vor Monat +670

    Safiya and Tyler trying their creations: Legit freaking out over the awesomeness
    Carly trying Safiya and Tyler's creations: "Oh."

    • Jesse Herrera
      Jesse Herrera Vor Monat

      Safiya and Tyler trying their creations / Legit freaking out over the awesomeness Carly trying Safiya and Tyler / s creations / * Oh . *

  • Ella Landqvist
    Ella Landqvist Vor Monat

    You forgot about arguably the best one, cinnamon bun!